A federal jury in Wilmington, Delaware delivered a mixed verdict in the latest legal battle between Qualcomm and Arm. Jurors found that Arm violated certain contractual obligations and interfered with Qualcomm’s business relationship with Meta. However, they rejected several other claims and awarded Qualcomm just $2 in total damages.
Both companies promptly declared victory. Qualcomm emphasized the findings that Arm breached its Architecture License Agreement (ALA) and intentionally interfered with its business. Arm highlighted its successful defense against several licensing claims and the absence of substantial monetary damages. Both interpretations have merit, although neither tells the entire story.
A Verdict With Two Winners
The jury found that Arm improperly withheld technical information, including OOBs and ACK patches, in violation of licensing obligations. It also found that Arm intentionally and negligently interfered with Qualcomm’s economic relationship with Meta. These findings establish that Arm crossed certain contractual and commercial boundaries in its dealings with a major customer.
However, the jury rejected Qualcomm’s claims involving Arm’s previous-best-deal licensing provisions, including requirements to investigate comparable agreements and offer terms within 10% of the previous best deal. Arm also prevailed on claims involving support and maintenance and certain peripheral intellectual property.
The most unusual aspect was the damages award. After extensive testimony, including approximately three hours of confidential financial evidence behind closed courtroom doors, the jury awarded Qualcomm $1 for contractual breaches and another $1 for interference with its Meta relationship.
Interestingly, during closing arguments Qualcomm’s attorney asked the jury to award at least $1 in damages. The jury awarded exactly $1 on each successful category of claims. Whether that reflected difficulty proving financial harm or a deliberate distinction between liability and damages is something the verdict itself does not explain.
Tirias Take
The judge’s decisions could matter more, and the verdict does not conclude the dispute. Judge Maryellen Noreika still faces important questions concerning contractual remedies and licensing obligations, including issues involving Arm’s proposed v10 architecture licensing terms.
Qualcomm has also pursued contractual remedies extending beyond the damages awarded by the jury. Depending on how the court interprets and applies the agreements, the remaining decisions carry potentially significant financial and competitive consequences.
The jury’s findings create an unusual foundation for those rulings. Arm prevailed on several important licensing questions, yet the same jury found contractual violations and intentional interference with Qualcomm’s business. The question that remains is what legal and commercial consequences follow from the conduct the jury found.
TIRIAS Research will examine the verdict, the competing corporate interpretations and the broader implications for the semiconductor industry in a forthcoming Forbes analysis.



